The Rail Accident Investigation Branch has released its report into a collision involving an LNER Azuma and an LNER HST.
At 21:41 on the 13th November 2019, an empty LNER Azuma was approaching Neville Hill Depot in Leeds and caught up and collided with the empty LNER HST which was also moving into the depot. The Azuma was travelling at 15 mph, and the HST was travelling in the same direction at 5mph.
No one was injured in the accident, but the trailing bogies on the second and third carriages and the trailing wheelset of the four carriage derailed.
The collision occurred because the driver was trying to reinstate an on-board system that he had recently isolated.
This was made worse by the driver accelerating too hard due to lack of familiarity with the train.
The driver had isolated the on-board system at Leeds because he was unable to set up the train management system due to LNER misunderstanding the “ambiguous documentation” from Hitachi.
The derailment of the Azuma happened because of the design of the Intercity Express Trains is susceptible to derailment in low-speed collisions. This was due to the use of high-strength couplers that had a large amount of movement.
The trains designers did not consider the impact of these features on the resistance to a derailment at low speed.
The crashworthiness standard used to design the Azuma trains did not require the designers to consider a collision at speeds slower than 22.5 mph.
The RAIB has made five recommendations. Two recommendations are addressed to LNER and relate to correcting its understanding of the setup of the train management system and ensuring that the documentation provided by Hitachi has not led to any other safety issues. The other recommendations relate to:
- Hitachi to revisit the assessment of the design of the Intercity Express Train against the requirements of the crashworthiness standard
- LNER to assess the risk of a derailment of an Intercity Express Train involved in a low speed collision
- RSSB to consider whether it is appropriate for the crashworthiness standard to be modified.
Where Next?
RailAdvent Plus
Support the website and get benefits in return
RailAdvent News
The latest railway news
RailAdvent Shop
Railway Prints, DVD’s / Blu-Ray’s and more
LocoStop Community
Come and share your railway pictures.
Mainline UK Steam Info
Upcoming mainline steam tours/loco movements
Responses
That Azuma train took the worst hit.
A 10mph collision completely obliterated its front end… Any thoughts on crashworthiness at say 125mph?
Thanks for the interesting comment.
Although you only published 3 of the stated 5 comments; there should be a sixth comment, that the driver should look where he was going. It seems that the investigation attempts to exonerate the driver and blame the train maker, the instructions supplied, the couplings, anything but driver error.
So apparently both trains were travelling at slow speed but one of them was heading in the right direction but they collided. Was it due to signalling errors that come of caused the minor accident.
They both was entering a depot as permitted, they stack on the arrival roads like many places do, just lack of concentration & training as reporter says
True.