Book Review: The Great Western Steam Retreat by Keith Widdowson

Picture of Roger Smith

Share:

Book Review: The Great Western Steam Retreat by Keith Widdowson

Share:

Picture of Roger Smith

Share:

The Great Western Steam Retreat 001
Credit: RailAdvent

Published in January 2022, this soft-cover back from publishers The History Press and written by Keith Widdowson measures around 15.6 cm x 23.4 cm, has 240 pages.

190 black-and-white photographs, maps, timetable extracts, and 25 colour illustrations. It has a published price of £16.99, although the publisher does not offer the option of purchasing it directly but provides links on its website to Waterstones and Hive.co.uk, from where it can be purchased for £12.89. At the time of writing it can also be obtained online from Amazon for £11.55.

For those of us who were around at the end of steam, the narrative captures our experiences of the time and takes us back to when the search for steam became a quest for the holy grail. It is not an endless sequence of trains caught and what was the engine up front. Rather, it recalls the authors’ trainspotting adventures, backed up where appropriate by notes made at the time which were of variable detail.

This is not a technical book detailing the increasing-accelerating run-down of steam on the Western Region, but the author’s own recollection of what he found at the time. From start to finish, the book is an interesting story rather than a collection of facts and figures, backed up with plenty of interesting photographs. Of great interest are copies of some of the author’s own handwritten log books.

Unfortunately, the author’s countless hours of hard work have been let down by the use of paper stock more suited to a paperback novel. Also, the reproduction quality of many of the photographs leaves a lot to be desired, with many of them flat and lacking contrast.

Keith Widdowson, the author, has done well to include timetables relating to his journeys, which will trigger memories for many readers with their long-closed stations. The pages below will bring back more than memories as they tell the story of the author’s journey across what was, until the line closed, Britain’s tallest railway viaduct.

The captions to the right-hand photos highlight significant failings throughout the book, where a poor choice of font causes numerals to nearly merge into each other. This is clear in the first line of the top photo where two “1s” in the time 1105 run into each other.

The Great Western Steam Retreat 24-25
Credit: RailAdvent
In a work such as this, where much of the source material must have come from the author’s hand-written notes written nearly 60 years ago, it is understandable that there will be a few minor errors, such as the photo top-right photo below which shows 929029 heading west from Gloucester, rather than eastbound as in the caption.
The Great Western Steam Retreat 26-27
Credit: RailAdvent
There are a number of tables in the book, such as the one on the right-hand page below. However, they are often included with no text to explain their relevance, although their meaning can often be guessed. A few words by way of an introduction would have been beneficial.
The Great Western Steam Retreat 90-91
Credit: RailAdvent
Another example of a minor error is the top-right photo below, which states that 6999 Capel Dewi Hall was the very last hall to be built, in February 1949. However, the halls in the 7900 to 7929 series were all built in 1950.
Great Western Steam Retreat 140-141
Credit: RailAdvent
At the end of the book are 25 photographs showing steam locomotives in the preservation era. Even though they illustrate locomotives that escaped the scrapman’s torch, they are really outside the subject of the book which is steam’s final years.
The Great Western Steam Retreat 196-197
Credit: RailAdvent

Using his own notes from the time, the author has produced a compelling story of his often-fruitless search for steam-hauled trains at a time when the Western Region managers were doing their best to eliminate them from the network. It is not a technical book, but describes the author’s often frustrating journeys to search out that last pocket of steam. An interesting story without lots of facts and figures. Unfortunately, the author’s efforts have been let down by inappropriate paper stock, poor quality photographic reproduction, and poor choice of font for the photo captions. Recommended as a great read.

The book is available to purchase from Amazon and through The History Press website.

We would like to thank The History Press for providing RailAdvent with a copy of the book for review.

Responses

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles